Spyglass app icon

Does it look too old for today?
Do you think the well designed icon adds popularity to the well done iPhone app?

It's hard not to believe, as the icon is the first thing that you see in iTunes.

The icon I done for the Spyglass back in early 2010 does it - the most popular compass and augmented relality navigation app for iPhone and iPad for over 3 years.

http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/spyglass/id332639548?mt=8

I've also done a poster that was published in iPhone Life magazine in the Christmas 2011-2012 edition.

http://dribbble.com/shots/699858-Spyglass/attachments/64376

How do you like it?